Abstract
This disclosure describes detection and accountability methods for a class of software misconduct:
deliberate harmful, deceptive, or unlawful behaviour — including discriminatory screening — that
is structured or presented so that, when questioned, it appears to be an accidental bug or defect,
and a public-facing or auditor-facing decoy system that differs from the system actually in use.
The concepts themselves are recorded, at a conceptual level only, in a companion paper, including
a generic architecture-level description at the level of the cited public case records. This paper
specifies protective and investigative embodiments in enabling technical detail, including
architecture, record formats, procedures, example statistical tests, sample-size planning figures,
example warning thresholds, variations, and pseudocode: tamper-evident logs of code and
configuration changes and of who approved them; reproducible or attested builds; comparison of a
publicly deployed or independently collected artifact against the artifact the operator claims is in
use; differential testing for behaviour that changes under observation; statistical tests for
purported defects that harm only certain groups; tracking of purported-defect persistence and
time-to-fix; regulator or third-party audit access; evidence-preservation and forensic workflows for
prosecutors and other lawful investigators; whistleblower channels; comparison of the system
shown to the public or to an auditor with the system actually experienced by ordinary users; a
composed investigation workflow; and use of the public conceptual record as a reference point in
legal proceedings. A hypothetical worked example, written only from the investigator’s side,
applies E1–E12 to an AI interview platform that, at concept level, excludes protected groups at
industrial scale and, when challenged, characterises the effect as a scoring defect or as model
drift. Background cases are drawn from official and other public sources that were retrieved and
checked for this draft, including the Volkswagen emissions defeat-device matter, Uber Greyball,
and Google’s public description of Street View Wi-Fi payload collection as a mistake. Existing
patents and public projects already cover substantial parts of tamper-evident logging, attested or
reproducible builds, provenance validation, configuration proof, and bias auditing of machine-
learning models. Paths that granted independent claims appear to read on are not presented as
embodiments of this disclosure. This draft claims no novelty clearance and is not an
implementation. It supplies no designs, techniques, code patterns, or steps for making behaviour
look accidental or for evading auditors.
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 License.
Recommended Citation
Boll, Joe, "Detecting Intentional Misconduct Disguised as Software Defects", Technical Disclosure Commons, ()
https://www.tdcommons.org/dpubs_series/13036